Friday 8 December 2023

Shadow of a Doubt (1943)

1988 MCA HiFi VHS: Not particularly great sounding. In the past, I might have attributed the lack of detail above 7 kHz to it being sourced from higher generation elements, but now I'd wager that some form of noise management was applied, possibly in the analogue domain. 

1989 MCA LaserDisc [40112]: The same mastering as the VHS tape.

2005 R1 Universal DVD - Masterpiece Collection: Moderately more detail >7 kHz than the VHS/LaserDisc. There's nothing objectively remarkable about it, though.

2013 Universal Blu-ray: A lossless version of the Masterpiece DVD track, so the best among these.

2022 Universal UHD Blu-ray: Quite a bit more noise reduction than the DVD/blu-ray, removing basically all the new clarity brought by that mastering and making it sound like the VHS/LD. 






No comments:

Post a Comment