Monday, 20 July 2020

Double Indemnity (1944)

1989 MCA LaserDisc [21004]: Fairly natural sounding, although not without noise management. It has some high-frequency crackle during loud moments, most audible during the opening and end music.

1991 MCA LaserDisc [21004]: A digital version of the earlier track. No additional mastering work, so this is the most detailed track overall.

2000s R2 Universal DVD: The least detailed track. Noise gating has removed quiet sounds throughout: pops and crackle are gone, but so are subtle body movements, breaths, and sighs. This was released in Spain.

2006 R1 Universal DVD - Legacy Edition: More detailed than the earlier DVD mastering, but still very muffled and slightly noise gated.

2012 Masters of Cinema Blu-ray: Like the Legacy DVD.

2014 Universal Blu-ray: Like the Legacy DVD.

2022 Criterion UHD Blu-ray: A new mastering. Little to no noise gating, so quiet sounds haven't been removed and EQ-wise it resembles the LD mastering. Less hiss reduction than the non-LD releases, but still a decent amount (nothing above 8 kHz). Preferable to the DVDs and previous blu-rays, but the attempt to remove all distortion leaves loud segments and some dialogue dull and unnatural next to the LaserDiscs.







6/9/2022: Added the 1988 MCA LaserDisc, the Criterion UHD, and a new comparison clip

1 comment:

  1. Touch of Evil was a weird case on the blu-ray (Universal edition)

    The reconstructed version sounds bad but the theatrical version sounds really good from what I sampled of it

    ReplyDelete